![]() Advocates for eliminating the electoral college system were criticized by the republic-not-a-democracy crowd as being for democracy while those who wished to keep the electoral college described themselves as being in favor of the far-more-preferable republican style of government.įor example, at The Federalist, Donna Carol Voss writes: "A majority of the population appears to support this idea, so I will invoke the republic-not-a-democracy claim to illustrate that the majority should be ignored."Īlso key to these claims is to invoke the authority of "the Founding Fathers" - by which is meant the pro-centralization nationalists and not the Anti-Federalists - for the usual reasons that anyone appeals to authority rather than offer a real argument.Ī recent example of this phenomenon emerged late last year in the debate over the electoral college. ![]() "I don't like your idea, and since it involves aspects that are democratic or majoritarian, I'll invoke the republic-not-a-democracy claim to discredit your idea.".This claim is generally invoked when the user believes one of the following: ![]() The claim that the United States political system is "a republic, not a democracy" is often heard in libertarian and conservative circles, and is typically invoked whenever the term "democracy" is used in any favorable context.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |